Brothers Fight continues the more dramatic opening, but Niece! sets the rather more subdued tone that pervades the lengthy middle of the score. Like the film itself, much of the Japanese style in the music fairly superficial in its incorporation. Under the Greenwood Tree is a song performed by (I think - one annoying feature of an iTunes download is the paucity of credits provided) Doyle himself which is a typical Doyle melody, but with plucked pentatonic backing. Another song, Blow Blow, continues in this vein; there's no attempt to make the melody sound Japanese, just the way it's arranged, which is very low key, but equally lovely. Indeed, low key sums up the score's general mood, but, anchored by a memorable main theme, it doesn't lose too much focus, There are a couple of playful interludes to rouse the listener, notably the brief but delightful Trip Audrey. Only in the later tracks does the music move above a dull roar; even titles that suggest something more exciting - all but the last minute or so of Lion Attack, for example - are as picturesque as the rest.
However, as the machinations of the lead characters start to resolve, Doyle opens the music out and Weddings and A Lover & His Lass inject a little more of the outgoing, sunny optimism that marked out Much Ado About Nothing. Indeed, Doyle repeats the concept of having an ensemble, choral finale in A Lover & His Lass with another delightful and memorable melody (albeit a touch Christmassy in execution, but that's no bad thing), surely destined to go down as a compilation staple. As is the Violin Romance, a gorgeous summary of the main themes, that closes the album. I'm at something of a loss to draw a definite conclusion about As You Like It; a little light pruning of the middle tracks wouldn't have gone amiss. It certainly doesn't have the dramatic or melodic variety of his Much Ado despite being absolutely gorgeous from start to finish. If the rating seems a bit mean, then it just shows that ratings are all relative. A delightful score, if just not as strong as his finest.
Rating ~
Total Time ~ 59:18