Naturally, the first thing to wonder is what kind of tone Newman adopts for Finding Nemo and the answer is somewhat unsurprising to the seasoned Newman fan: eclectic. There is certainly little attempt to follow Randy's style, even if there are some more obvious animation scoring moments, notably the witty Short-Term Dory - Thomas Newman does Carl Stalling, which is as delightful as it is surprising. Toy marches are adopted for First Day and Mr Ray, Scientist, both of which recall those delightful scherzos that enlivened Oscar and Lucinda. While Newman is quite at home doing witty, one thing he doesn't tackle much is action, but of course any family adventure film needs a little action and the approach here is to use fairly limited resources and make the best of them. Friends Not Food is a case in point, highlighting low end strings and syncopated rhythms, the results are edgy with a real element of danger, but without being overwhelming. However, the later tracks use increased orchestral forces, notably Fish in my Hair, All Drains Lead to the Ocean and Fishing Grounds.
One thing that Newman avoids is any attempt to lighten the dramatic episodes. The tone is generally somewhat playful, but when called for, the drama really bites (as it were) and this is definitely to the score's advantage. Sometimes the comedy is juxtaposed with the serious material and from the exuberant action of Jellyfish Forest, there is a real element of danger in Stay Awake. However, there are plenty of little jazzy moments, but all with the typically unusual Newman twist. Fish-O-Rama and Darla Filth Offramp are both great fun and in the manner of the eclectic style of furnishing, all the elements are so good that even though they aren't really musically matched in either tone or style, they sound great together.
In his continuing attempt to break the American market, the album concludes with Robbie Williams crooning the classic Beyond the Sea which is a great way to end. Much though I admire Randy Newman, his Pixar scores aren't his greatest works, tuneful and enjoyable though they are. However, by sticking more closely to his dramatic style, Thomas' debut for Pixar is every bit as engaging as his live action scores and quite a bit more enjoyable than many of them. The presence of 40 tracks over an hour is no great detriment as many of them run together seemlessly. As it was unlikely he'd produce anything too heavy for Pixar, there's little surprise to note that Finding Nemo represents his most accessible, lively and engaging score to date. It might not be his best or even most inventive, but there is no denying its sheer entertainment value.
Rating ~ 
Total Time ~ 60:21