Thomas Newman is a composer whose scores can rarely be compared to the work of others, but in this instance, there is a definite hint of Hans Zimmer's charming score to Driving Miss Daisy (also about racial prejudice in the deep south and also starring Jessica Tandy), most notably in the piano riffs for the Main Title, the two Night Baseball segments and the latter stages of The Bee Chamber. Zimmer and Newman also both feature a gentle clarinet solo for the main theme, but Newman's is a real one and a lot more gentle in approach. Given the very similar subject matter and location, it's not a great surprise there's some crossover, most likely due to temp tracking. The similarities are more glancing than glaring and only make up a fairly small proportion of the overall music. Although replete with jauntier passages, many of the cues are more considered, with Newman employing a warmer than usual string sound and a typically subtle approach to the drama. The occasional addition of Williams' vocals is a good dramatic move, as well as one that suggests the location - unlike, for example, Elfman's recent score to Hulk where the vocals do neither of these things.
I have often complained that the non score cues on his albums conflict with Newman's carefully crafted atmosphere, but in this case the two songs and single, brief piano tune fit in rather better. Unfortunately, when performing on her own, Williams adopts the approach of improvising a whole sub melody around each note, so each syllable is treated to half a dozen notes close to the actual one required. It might be stylistically appropriate for spirituals of this type, but I find it very unappealing and couldn't help but be reminded of a spoof of this type of singing that appeared in The Simpsons where the national anthem took ages to perform as the singer warbled endlessly around each note. However, her vocals within the score itself are wonderful and overall Newman's score is a delight. Despite it's brevity and scarcity, well worth picking up. Soulful.
Rating ~
Total Time ~ 32:56