In terms of quality, 2005 has been an above average year for Horner and Legend of Zorro continues this trend. Admittedly, what goes for the original applies here as much is similar, the main Zorro and love themes are reprised and the new melodic material isn't especially notable, or used with much frequency. Legend is more a matter of refinement and refashioning of the original material. Indeed, it's to Horner's credit that he comes up with some new and improved ways to present the same ideas, either with added counterpoint or refashioned orchestrations. The action cues seem a little tighter this time around, notably the witty Cortez Ranch and the lengthy showdown on The Train. It's an enjoyable pleasure to hear Horner writing action that doesn't just bang away, marking time, but provides some tuneful and meaningful commentary on the story and characters.
Depending on your predilection for such things, many listeners will be pleased to note that the original's (quite good) spinoff song is not reprised here, nor is there a replacement. The danger of ratings is that they can seem more or less ambitious over time and my top star ranking of the original is probably a little on the generous side in retrospect. There is some scope for noting that the sequel is, in some ways, superior to its predecessor, the refinements all working toward a more constantly engaging and thoroughly enjoyable album. Of course, the basic material was all there to be rearranged so it's hard to give full credit for what is a very similar score, but that takes little away from its entertainment value. If you enjoyed the first, this is more of the same, but arguably presented even better.
Rating ~ 
Total Time ~ 75:34