Signs is a sort of updated Close Encounters for a more paranoid and naval gazing age, although here the aliens are largely in the background and the film focuses mainly on Mel Gibson's character and his family. Still, Shyamalan is a director who enjoys instilling a sense of unease in his audience and between unseen potential dangers with potent silence, the use of music becomes even more critical. For what becomes a relatively quiet first half, the brief Main Titles are a thrilling Bernard Herrmann inspired flurry of strings and booming brass, that has an intensity that comes as a surprise. What only becomes clear after a few listens to the whole score is that almost all of it is based on a simple cyclical motif, but employed in various orchestrations and with varying density. In the hands of a less skilled composer, this could render the score tedious and repetitive, but Howard has enough tricks to prevent it becoming tired.
The first few tracks play the main motif as though it is being echoed, perhaps the only disappointing side effect is to render it stylistically similar to Mark Snow's X-Files main theme. Also, a few too many of the early tracks seem to start the same, although they invariably go off on their own tangent. One of the smartest moves by Howard is to not always maintain an entirely spooky atmosphere. In the Cornfield turns it alternately major and minor, suggesting a little more humanity. However, the intensity does build and the more explosive moments are utterly compelling. Howard's action music is usually good, but the level of invention on display here is remarkable, especially since most of it is, again, derived from the same central idea. The Hand of Fate Part I is a brutal assault on the senses, but is still totally musical - it would have been so easy for it to descend into a chaotic mess.
While the obviously brilliant parts show their brilliance from the outset, the album as a whole requires more careful listening. Yes, the first half is quite quiet, but Howard rarely allows the music to become directionless and while it has a similar feel, the mood and pace change frequently enough to avoid the album from flagging, which it so easily could. A couple of tracks probably should have been omitted - for example, Baby Monitor is largely redundant being both short and revealing no new ideas. The recording quality is notably superb, the brass is rich and vibrant during the exciting later cues and makes appreciating the attention to detail of the inner orchestral parts easy. For all that, it's one of those impressive efforts that combines plenty of atmosphere, with enough melodic material and such is highly recommended. Oh yes, the cover art is most appealing.
Rating ~ 