After the runaway success of Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves, the historical swashbuckler was back in fashion, although few were nearly so successful. Many were updated for the TV generation - more recent films now including seemingly obligatory martial arts in the fight scenes, what would Errol Flynn have thought?! Where Korngold accompanied Flynn on his adventures, so Kamen's music accompanies Charlie Sheen, Kiefer Sutherland and, er Chris O'Donnell on theirs and while it doesn't quite have the Korngoldian pizzazz, the results are still satisfying. The album opens with the rough voices of Rod Stewart and Bryan Adams, with the somewhat more silky tones of Sting, in the Anything I Do shameless cash in song, All for Love. It's not a bad effort, but never quite reached the popularity of the earlier Adams song (which to many is probably a blessed relief) and the sound of the two crooners trying to out-rasp each other, and Sting, is plenty enjoyable.

One thing that Korngold never really bothered with was period feeling, he stuck firmly to his late romantic style, but Kamen goes for a more quasi-authentic approach. Well, there are harpsichords in it anyway. The opening choral cue is surprisingly liturgical and it's something of a disappointment that this material doesn't recur. It has moments that sound like every passionate, but religious, choral cue you've ever heard, although I'd be hard pressed to cite a specific precedent. This being a period adventure, there are some more modern sounding action cues, although Kamen includes a few Purcell style trumpet trills and fortunately does nothing so offensive as to include any synths. It is perhaps a surprise that much of it is string led, especially the energetic The Cardinal's Coach which instantly conjures images of horse drawn carriages racing through misty forests.

The score goes faux (pre-)baroque in the quieter passages, but the song melody isn't really suitable for the style of the underscore and so doesn't really feature. There are enough fine moments to make The Three Musketeers worth hearing, but it just lacks that indefinable something to make it a great score. Overall, it's a better and more consistently entertaining listen than Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves; the basic thematic material is perhaps less striking, but the action doesn't give the feeling of a composer marking time, even if there are fewer obvious highlights. The track listing is notable for the authentic sounding subtitles - Lament, Rigadoon, Gavotte etc. - and if it were anyone but Kamen, I'd say it was the composer being pretentious, but I'm inclined to think the music was written to be authentic to the descriptions. Not perhaps Kamen at his finest, but as a composer disinclined to do anything but a professional job, still worth checking out.

Rating ~

  1. All For Love (4:36)
    Performed by Bryan Adams, Rod Stewart & Sting
  2. The Cavern of Cardinal Richelieu (2:55)
  3. D'Artagnan (3:17)
  4. Athos, Porthos and Aramis (5:21)
  5. Sword Fight (3:18)
  6. King Louis XIII, Queen Anne and Constance - Lady in Waiting (5:03)
  7. The Cardinal's Coach (4:41)
  8. Cannonballs (3:27)
  9. M'Lady De Winter (3:27)
  10. The Fourth Musketeer (5:20)

Total Time ~ 42:45