Despite his obvious brilliance as a composer, there is a little part of me that wishes Thomas Newman wrote slightly less eclectic scores. It can be a touch frustrating when some brilliant idea pipes up, but only lasts a minute or two, never to be heard of again. The thought of Thomas Newman doing sci-fi is about as tantalising as it was when he did his first Pixar score, Finding Nemo, but in fairness Wall-E isn't really Star Trek or Serenity style sci-fi, but more of a robot love story. The premise (and that it has almost no regular dialogue, mostly R2-D2 esque bleeps) would sound rather unpromising if it weren't for the fact that Pixar rarely (if ever) disappoint. The album opens, perhaps a little oddly, with Put On Your Sunday Clothes from Hello! Dolly, performed by Michael Crawford; an excerpt from It Only Takes a Moment from the same show appears later on. The brief liner notes by director Andrew Stanton shed little light on these inclusions, but I have no doubt they will make perfect sense in the film itself. Either way, Newman's score is so typically quirky that they don't seem particularly out of place.

As noted, this is not epic sci-fi and so Newman treats it as a sweet, but witty love story. OK, there is no sweeping love theme and First Date is positively retro in its use of of 60s "ba ba ba" (no, not like sheep) pop chorus. It counts as one of several great ideas that are only heard once - one could imagine it being extended into some brilliant Michel Legrand style pastiche. Alas. Of course, much of the score is considerably more "typical" Thomas Newman (if there is such a thing), many plinking, percussive passages with shimmering strings - 72 Degrees and Sunny is a prime example. The watery textures of Finding Nemo are actually in evidence throughout, but they seem just as appropriate for outer space as they did for the deep blue. Also much in evidence is Newman's comedic side, not perhaps his most renowned, but it shines through here; Typing Bot, the hilarious advert BNL and M-O are all delightful and occasionally really quite silly (but not annoying, Newman is too classy for that), however, alas again, rather brief. While largely intimate, there are a couple of more exciting moments, notably Thrust, Eve Retrieve, Mutiny and particularly the surprisingly dark Rogue Robots. These hint at what a more typical sci-fi film might get from Newman.

The album closes (save for a brief score coda) with Down to Earth performed and co-written by Peter Gabriel. Even after a few listens, I'm not entirely sure what to make of it; I suppose Newman does folksy rock is the best I can come up with. There's definitely plenty of Newman's style there and the lyrics aren't too toe curling, although I suspect plenty will find it rather mawkish. Wall-E certainly takes a good number of listens to appreciate all of it, but then that goes for most Newman scores. He's not a composer who writes in long structures and all the nuances won't be picked up on the first listen or two, but as ever, perseverance pays plentiful dividends. A word must also go to the superbly retro packaging. OK, it's basically like the Lost World cardboard diorama, but without pop-up dinosaurs, but the no frills cardboard and pleasingly original approach to the graphic design works rather well. One almost longs for an LP version to turn it into a piece of artwork worth hanging on the wall (as a number of soundtrack album covers deserve).

Rating ~

  1. Put On Your Sunday Clothes (1:17)
    Performed by Michael Crawford & Company
  2. 2815 A.D. (3:28)
  3. Wall-E (2:00)
  4. The Spaceship (1:41)
  5. EVE* (1:02)
    *Composed by Thomas Newman and Peter Gabriel
  6. Thrust (0:41)
  7. Bubble Wrap (0:50)
  8. La Vie En Rose (3:24)
    Performed by Louis Armstrong
  9. Eye Surgery (0:40)
  10. Worry Wait (1:19)
  11. First Date (1:19)
  12. Eve Retrieve (2:19)
  13. The Axiom (2:24)
  14. BNL** (0:20)
    Written by Bill Bernstein and Thomas Newman
  15. Foreign Contaminant (2:06)
  16. Repair Ward (2:20)
  17. 72 Degrees and Sunny (03:12)
  18. Typing Bot (0:47)
  19. Septuacentennial (0:15)
  20. Gopher (0:40)
  21. Wall-E's Pod Adventure (1:13)
  22. Define Dancing* (2:23)
    Composed by Thomas Newman and Peter Gabriel
  23. No Splashing No Diving (0:47)
  24. All That Love's About (0:37)
  25. M-O (0:46)
  26. Directive A-113 (2:05)
  27. Mutiny! (1:29)
  28. Fixing Wall-E (2:08)
  29. Rogue Robots (2:02)
  30. March of the Gels (0:54)
  31. Tilt (2:00)
  32. The Holo-Detector (1:07)
  33. Hyperjump (1:04)
  34. Desperate Eve (0:56)
  35. Static (1:43)
  36. It Only Takes a Moment (1:07)
    Performed by Michael Crawford
  37. Down to Earth*** (5:58)
    Music by Peter Gabriel and Thomas Newman, Lyrics by Peter Gabriel, Performed by Peter Gabriel
  38. Horizon 12.2 (1:27)

Total Time ~ 61:50